Today was the first Thursday in May – the National Day of Prayer. Yes, since 1952, the first Thursday of May every year has been set aside as a day for our nation to “turn to God in prayer and meditation.” Although the official national observance as we know it now has been in effect since 1952, the practice goes back much further. In fact, it goes back to the Continental Congress which called for a day of fasting and prayer on July 20, 1775.
It would seem that today was the final time we will have a National Day of Prayer. On April 15, 2010, U.S. District Judge Barbara Crabb ruled the National Day of Prayer to be unconstitutional. An appeal to this ruling was filed on April 22, 2o1o. We will see what happens.
Let’s break this down a little. As of today, I have now been a Christian for 22 years. For 22 years, I keep hearing people talk about the “separation of church and state.” Let’s be clear about this, that phrase IS NOT IN THE CONSTITUTION. The phrase “separation of church and state” came from a letter written by Thomas Jefferson in response to the Danbury Baptists, who expressed concern that politicians would start dictating what religion people were allowed to practice. You can read both letters here:
Letter to Thomas Jefferson from the Danbury Baptists (October 7, 1801)
Thomas Jefferson’s response letter (January 1, 1802)
So, what then, does the Constitution say? The First Amendment states:
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.”
Now, I am not a lawyer. Judge Crabb clearly had reasons to rule the National Day of Prayer unconstitutional. A main point of the case was the Freedom From Religion Foundation (an atheist organization) concerned about what a National Day of prayer could lead to if not stopped. However, there are also lawyers and judges who disagree with her ruling. So, let’s take a stab at walking through this.
The first part of the First Amendment forbids the Government from making a law that would establish a religion. Let me ask: what religion is being mandated by the National Day of Prayer? Many observances end up being ecumenical assemblies (of which I am not a fan). Can Jewish people participate? Yes. Can Muslims participate? Yes. Can Christians participate? Yes. Can Hindus participate? Yes. Can atheists participate? YES! Remember, the National Day of Prayer calls for a day of prayer and meditation. An atheist will not pray, but they can meditate. So, exactly what religion is the Government forcing you to observe in the National Day of Prayer? None. In fact, they aren’t even forcing you to participate at all. They are simply inviting any of the 90% of the population who pray to seek God, or whatever god they worship, on behalf of the nation’s well-being.
However, the Amendment then goes on to forbid the Government from making any laws that prohibit the free exercise of religion. Now, if the National Day of Prayer is no longer acknowledged as a “national holiday,” what will happen if 20 people decide to gather in front of their local city hall next year on their lunch break to pray? Will they be kicked off the property? If so, has their free exercise of a religious practice been taken away? Hmm… that may actually be unconstitutional.
America has been a free nation since its beginning. The National Day of Prayer has been an invitation for praying folks to pray for the nation. I have heard no reports of anyone being disciplined or harmed in any way for failure to acknowledge or participate in the National Day of Prayer. Imagine that, you are free to take part or you are free to not take part.
What is the harm in keeping a National Day of Prayer? Better yet, how is it that one woman has the power to make this choice? This is the same issue with Christmas. Should a city hall have a nativity? Sure – I don’t think taxpayers should pay for it, but if someone else provides it – go for it. And let’s allow other religious displays to be set out, as well. Let everyone celebrate. Locally, a nearby city hall had put a gay pride flag out on display to acknowledge the homosexual community. OK, fine, now fly a Christian flag. Oh, no – separation of church and state, right? So, it’s OK for the Government to encourage people to celebrate anything, as long as it is not a religion?
The Freedom From Religion Foundation was concerned that the National Day of Prayer could result in some type of persecution against those who do not participate. OK, now that you have won this battle, what will your victory lead to? What will happen to a group of Christians, for example, who want to gather at the most important landmark in their city to pray for their city on the first Thursday of May next year? Will that activity be considered illegal? Congrats! You defeated something that was Constitutional and have ushered in something that is actually unconstitutional. But I don’t think they really care about the Constitution, I think what they care about is waging war on religion in general.
Why is it that smoke pours out of their ears at the thought of Christians praying at city hall? What would I do if a group of atheists gathered at city hall to… not pray? I’d offer to bring some donuts so they could fellowship afterwards. Go for it! That’s the key to the freedom of speech – it’s equal freedom, even for those who disagree with your fundamental core values.
When I was in high school, this plow was used to discourage me from conducting an after school Bible study. After the school realized it would be a violation to keep me from doing it, they said, “But if we let you have your Bible study, we would have to let the Satanists have a meeting, as well.” They were taken back when I responded by saying, “Yes, you would.” But that’s the way it works.
This is a little snippy, but here goes – taking prayer out of school has really seemed to work well. Violence, drug use, etc. have all skyrocketed since then. Are we sure we want to take this strategy to a national level?
May 6th, 2010 | Category: Points to Ponder | Leave a comment